The Wake Up Label Letter

The Wake Up Label Letter

The #1 Reason Your PB&J Isn’t as Wholesome as It Looks

PB&J is marketed as the ultimate “kid-friendly” meal. But peel back the label on the bread, peanut butter, and jelly, and you’ll see that the classic combo is fueling inflammation, gut issues, and lon

Wake Up and Read The Labels's avatar
Wake Up and Read The Labels
Aug 20, 2025
∙ Paid
6
1
Share

🚫 The Bread: Dave’s Killer Bread

At first glance, it sounds healthy—“organic,” “21 grains and seeds,” “whole wheat.” But what’s actually inside?

  • Lectins & Phytic Acid → Found in wheat, oats, rye, and seeds. These anti-nutrients can bind to minerals (like zinc and iron), making them harder to absorb. Long-term? Mineral deficiencies, digestive stress, and leaky gut.

  • Gluten → Triggers inflammation and gut permeability in many people—even those without celiac. That’s why so many report bloating, brain fog, or joint pain after bread.

  • Grains Overload → “21 grains and seeds” might sound like variety, but it’s actually 21 sources of potential gut irritants. Actually, the way this label reads….it is literally whole wheat, can sugar and then a grains and seeds mix. You are eating gluten but thinking you are eating a bunch of seeds. Consider it just a side item. Instead of easy-to-digest fuel, your body’s left fighting off bloat, inflammation, and fatigue.


🚫 The Peanut Butter: Jif

Jif’s label reads simple, but it’s a health trap.

  • Roasted Peanuts + Sugar → Roasting creates oxidized fats, and sugar spikes insulin. Together, this raises risk for diabetes and heart disease.

  • Mold (Aflatoxins) → Peanuts are one of the most mold-prone crops, which can stress the liver and immune system. You MUST find mold-free. I list these at the bottom.

  • Rapeseed & Soybean Oil → Highly refined seed oils = inflammatory omega-6 overload. The worst of the worst that will make you gain weight.

  • Mono & Diglycerides → Industrial additives linked to obesity, diabetes, and even heart disease.


🚫 The Jelly: Smucker’s

The “fruit spread” marketed to moms as healthy is basically liquid sugar.

  • Concord Grapes (GMO + pesticides) → Heavily sprayed with toxic chemicals.

  • Corn Syrup + High Fructose Corn Syrup → Spike blood sugar, the worst sweeteners on a label, literally. They drive insulin resistance, linked to obesity and fatty liver.

  • Pectin → Sounds harmless, but when combined with refined sugars, it can worsen gut imbalance.

  • Sodium Citrate → A processed additive that contributes to bloating and digestive distress.

Translation? A PB&J made with these three brands = sugar bomb + inflammation sandwich.


✅ Clean Swaps

You don’t have to ditch PB&J forever—you just need the right brands.

  • Bread: Pacha Bread (use code: wakeup) (grain-free, lectin-free, gluten-free, and gut-friendly).

  • Peanut Butter: Maranatha Organic Peanut Butter (just peanuts + salt) be sure you get the one that says 2 Ingredients.

  • Jelly: St. Dalfour Fruit Spread (sweetened only with fruit juice).


✨ Paid Subscriber Perks:
Unlock the cleanest bread for kids, my #1 peanut butter swap - it is additive!!! , and my homemade jelly recipe (plus the other jelly brands) that actually supports gut health.

👉 [Upgrade below to get the swaps & recipe.]

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to The Wake Up Label Letter to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Jen Smiley
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture